In this last chapter, Henry mentally reviews the three significant stages of his battlefield experience. Regarding his second battle and his subsequent flight from the front, Henry attributes that behavior to nothing more than "the wild mistakes and ravings of a novice who didn't comprehend." Indeed that is probably a fair assessment since he was not the first soldier to run, nor would he be the last, and he did recover his courage to make a fine impression on his lieutenant at the next battle. Indeed his captain identified him as a fierce "wild cat". Also, then, when he led the troops as flag bearer, he was very courageous and, rightly so, because he stared into the face of the enemy and didn't back down. Henry's actions show great courage.
The only behavior which truly rests negatively on him — which truly places a heavy felling of guilt on him — is his treatment of the tattered soldier. When both are in the field, and the tattered soldier, wounded and disoriented, seeks to help Jim, Henry loses patience with him and leaves him. This "vision of cruelty," this "somber phantom of the desertion in the field," this recognition that "the light of his soul flickered with shame" troubles Henry greatly; however, he is able to rationalize this behavior because he decides to use this "sin" as a future force to control his "egotism," as a way to be sure that he remains always humble. He reasons that if he ever begins to feel that his courage exceeds all others, he need only remember that he didn't treat a wounded companion with decency, and that memory will work to bring back his humility. Indeed, for him to reason this way, he must truly be a "man," both of and in war, because he will face future battles, and, as the reader has seen, he has shown the courage and bravery needed to face the enemy squarely.
